Can You Challenge a Prenuptial Agreement in a New York Divorce?

Did you sign a prenuptial agreement before tying the knot?  At that time, it may have seemed a fair deal. However, what happens if you realize that the terms of your prenup are unfair or unjust as you file for divorce? Can you challenge it in court?

In this article, we will discuss the circumstances under which you may be able to invalidate a prenuptial agreement and why hiring an experienced New York divorce attorney is crucial for your success. So, let’s dive into this topic!

What Is a Prenuptial Agreement?

A prenuptial agreement is a legal contract that couples sign before they get married. It outlines how their assets and debts will be divided in the event of divorce or separation. Essentially, it allows both parties to protect their financial interests.

Typically, a prenup covers issues such as property division, spousal support, and inheritance rights. It can also include provisions for who gets custody of pets or how family heirlooms will be handled.

It’s essential to note that certain things cannot be included in a prenup – such as child custody arrangements – because these decisions must be made based on what is in the child’s best interest at the time of divorce.

While some people view prenups as unromantic or distrustful, they can provide peace of mind and clarity around finances if done correctly. However, it’s crucial to understand when a prenup is considered official and binding under New York law so that you don’t waste your time trying to challenge an iron-clad agreement.

When Is a Prenup Considered Official and Binding?

A prenuptial agreement is a legal document that outlines how assets will be divided in case of divorce or separation. However, just having a prenup does not automatically make it official and binding. There are certain criteria that must be met for a prenup to hold up in court.

Firstly, both parties must have voluntarily entered into the agreement without any coercion or pressure from the other party. This means that neither spouse can force the other to sign the document against their will.

Secondly, both parties must have had full knowledge of each other’s financial situation at the time of signing. This includes disclosing all assets, debts and income sources.

Thirdly, there should be no evidence of fraud or misrepresentation by either party during the creation and signing of the prenup. If one spouse was unaware of important information regarding finances and assets, then they may be able to challenge its validity.

Looking at these conditions, a New York divorce attorney may be able to challenge the prenuptial agreement you entered into on one of the following grounds.

a divorce lawyer can challenge an unfair prenup.

1. The Prenup Is Unconscionable

When a prenuptial agreement is deemed unconscionable, it means that the terms of the agreement are so one-sided and unfair that they shock the conscience. In other words, if enforcing such an agreement would be clearly unjust or oppressive, then it can be challenged in court.

Typically, New York courts will consider several factors to determine whether a prenup is unconscionable. These include things like whether both parties had enough time to review and negotiate the terms of the agreement; whether there was full financial disclosure by both parties; and whether each party had separate legal representation during negotiations.

If you believe that your prenuptial agreement is unconscionable, you’ll need to hire an experienced New York divorce attorney who can help you challenge its validity in court. Your lawyer will work with you to gather evidence supporting your claims of unconscionability and present them convincingly before a judge.

Ultimately, challenging a prenup on grounds of unconscionability can be difficult but not impossible. With skilled legal representation on your side, you may be able to successfully invalidate an unfair premarital agreement in your New York divorce case.

2. The Prenup Was Signed Under Duress

Sometimes, one spouse might feel pressured or coerced into signing the prenup. This is known as duress, and it can render a prenuptial agreement invalid in court. Duress occurs when one party uses threats or force to compel the other party to sign the document against their will.

If you believe that you were made to sign the prenup under duress, you need to show evidence of coercion. For example, if your partner threatened to call off the wedding unless you signed the agreement, that could be considered duress.

It’s important to note that feeling pressure or anxiety about signing a prenup is not sufficient grounds for invalidating it. The burden of proof lies with the challenging spouse who must demonstrate that they were forced into signing it.

Working with an experienced New York divorce attorney can help you build a strong case and increase your chances of success in challenging a prenuptial agreement signed under duress.

3. One of the Spouses Committed Prenup Fraud by Not Disclosing Assets

One of the common reasons why a prenuptial agreement can be challenged in a New York divorce is if one spouse committed fraud by not disclosing assets. It’s important to note that both parties must fully and honestly disclose all their assets before signing the prenup for it to be considered valid.

If it is discovered that one spouse failed to disclose an asset or lied about its value, this could be grounds for challenging the prenup. This type of fraudulent behavior undermines the purpose of a prenup, which is to ensure transparency and fairness in dividing property and debts.

It’s essential to work with an experienced New York divorce attorney who can help you gather evidence of non-disclosure or fraud. Your lawyer may hire forensic accountants or investigators who can uncover hidden assets.

If you suspect your spouse has committed fraud by not disclosing assets during your marriage or while creating your prenuptial agreement, contact an attorney immediately. They will guide you through the process of challenging the validity of your prenup in court.

An Experienced New York Divorce Attorney Will Help You Invalidate an Unfair Prenup!

Navigating a high-net-worth divorce with a prenuptial agreement in place can be a complicated and emotional process. But you must remember that there are options available if you believe your agreement is unfair. If you’re considering challenging a prenup in New York, the best course of action is to consult with an experienced divorce attorney who can help guide you through the legal process.

An experienced New York divorce attorney will have the knowledge and expertise necessary to evaluate your situation and determine whether challenging your prenup is a viable option. They’ll also be able to provide guidance on how to proceed with any legal challenges or negotiations that may arise during this process.

In short, if you believe that your prenup is unjust or was signed under duress, don’t hesitate to discuss this matter with your divorce lawyer. With the right support from an experienced New York divorce attorney at the Douglas Family Law Group, you’ll be better equipped to navigate this complex area of family law and ensure that your interests are protected every step of the way.

Call 914-598-8171 to schedule your first appointment with us!

Fill in your name, email and then hit "Download Now." That's it!​

Fill in your name, email and then hit "Download Now." That's it!​

Tell us where to send our latest podcast episodes